Knowledgebase

Sourdough Starter #890805

Asked December 14, 2024, 7:01 PM EST

I have recently, officially, been influenced to begin my sourdough journey! I am so excited! Rather than getting a starter from a friend or relative (in fear that I would kill it), I decided to make my own starter (proudly named “Taylor Sift!”). I started 6 days ago with 50 grams of unbleached King Arthur bread flour and 50 grams of spring water (bought from Meijer in a gallon). After 3 days of doing this process every 24 hours, there were bubbles forming, but no growth (I know I’m not supposed to expect growth after 3 days), but on day 5, I began discarding half and adding back in the 50g/50g mixture and repeating that since. Since then, no bubbles have been forming and when I take the cover off, there is a thick skin formed on the top of my starter, and while mixing, it just forms thick globs that are difficult to incorporate. 1) Have I done something wrong since the get-go? 2) Should I have expected bubbles so soon or after discarding? 3) Is the skin normal or alarming? 4) Should I just start over? Thank you for your help!

Gratiot County Michigan

Expert Response

Hi Michael!

Sourdough can be really tricky, and from my experience, there is no 'one size fits all' for how your starter will grow - it can take some starters up to 14 days to start growing. It sounds like you're on the right track; starters can still be revived if there are no bubbles. I would keep feeding it for a while, but make sure it has good conditions to grow. 

Some things to keep in mind:

- You could be experiencing a film due to the starter losing too much moisture. If you are using a paper towel or cheese cloth to cover it, that could be your problem. Try switching to a regular lid for your container or plastic wrap with a rubber band around the lip of the container. 

- Sourdough really likes a warm environment, which can be tricky in the winter. Wrap your container with a hand towel to help preserve some warmth, or move it to a smaller, warmer area. My personal favorite is my oven. Of course, don't turn on the oven to 'pre-warm' it, and make sure to always check the oven before you turn it on to bake anything. 

- Unless your tap water is very hard, you really don't need to use bottled water. When I feed my sourdough, I use lukewarm water from the tap (temperature like you are giving a bath to a baby). 

Personally, I keep my sourdough in a plastic container with a lid and store it long-term in the refrigerator. When I want to revive it, I discard straight from the refrigerator, then only feed (no further discards) for a couple of days until I have good bubbles and growth. When it is growing, I rest the lid on top of the container (without snapping it on) to let it get air while still preserving moisture. 


If you do not have growth after 14 days, I would start over for fear of growing harmful bacteria. You can also check out King Arthur for their tips! https://www.kingarthurbaking.com/recipes/sourdough-starter-recipe


Hope this helps, and good luck!

An Ask Extension Expert Replied December 17, 2024, 11:00 AM EST

Loading ...