Knowledgebase

Too Early Dormancy for My Red Buckeye? #846070

Asked August 17, 2023, 10:11 AM EDT

In late spring of 2017, I had a Newark, Ohio plant nursery install a 5-foot tall balled and burlapped (wire-caged) Red Buckeye in my Columbus, Ohio 43228 backyard. I was told by the nursery that the warranted tree needed to be and was planted with a wire cage around the tree root ball left intact. For the past 6 years I’ve noticed that the tree leaves brown and drop off between late July and mid-August. Should those leaves still be green and intact into September? Also, what I thought was root girdling at the base of the tree, I was told by a local arborist was not the case. Those twisted roots appear on the side of the tree that faces the prevailing winds from the west (see attached photos of my red buckeye tree taken 8/10/2023). Also, I took photos of a mature, over 10’ tall, Red Buckeye at the Chadwick Arboretum of The Ohio State University on 8/9/2023 and the leaves on it were still green and intact (see attached photos). Also, there was no twisting of the tree roots at the base of that tree. Why doesn’t my Red Buckeye retain its leaves like the Chadwick Arboretum Red Buckeye at the same time (early August) and why does my Red Buckeye show twisted roots that are not found on the Chadwick Arboretum Red Buckeye? Thank you, Ron Kenat

Franklin County Ohio

Expert Response

I think there are two questions here. (1) Why is the buckeye tree losing its leaves so early and (2) was it planted correctly.


There are a number of possible reasons why your tree is losing its leaves in August. First, buckeye trees typically lose their leaves earlier than other trees, usually in September. Your tree is getting brown leaves very early. From your picture, it appears to be in full sun which may be a problem since buckeye trees in their native habitat are often found as understory trees getting sun only part of each day. Because we’ve had several hot, dry weeks your tree may have developed leaf scorch. Since this has happened every year and your tree seems to be otherwise healthy there doesn’t seem to be anything you absolutely need to do since it would be difficult to find a way to shade it from the hot afternoon sun. However, you could help your tree survive by watering it when we have those hot, dry weeks. Also, you could put about three inches of mulch around it to help keep the moisture in. Be sure to keep the mulch away from the trunk of the tree (See Mulching Landscape Trees (psu.edu) for a more thorough explanation about how to mulch). For more information about growing buckeye trees you might want to read Seven things to know about growing an Ohio buckeye tree (dispatch.com) and Ohio Buckeye | Ohio Department of Natural Resources (ohiodnr.gov).


As to the other question: was it planted correctly, the answer is probably. There are two theories about the best way to plant balled and burlapped trees and it seems both ways have good reasons and both work well. For a more thorough discussion about that you might want to read https://extension.illinois.edu/news-releases/tips-planting-balled-burlapped-trees-long-term-health-success.


Loading ...