Knowledgebase

Poor parsnip root development when grown in compost #843942

Asked August 03, 2023, 7:51 AM EDT

Our raised beds are filled with 100% sifted compost. Most every vegetable we grow seems to be happy (beans, tomatoes, carrots, cukes, cabbages, kale, basil, hot peppers) but the parsnips have poor root development. Great top development, though. I've read conflicting information regarding parsnip's need for nitrogen. I have not over-fertilized the parsnips. Is compost a good medium for parsnips or not? And the heat doesn't seem to have adversely affected the other veggies. Any ideas?

Wabasha County Minnesota

Expert Response

Good morning Richard and thank you for reaching out to ask2.extension. 
parsnips grow best in soil that is amended to be loosely packed, so I think you need some soil for them to grow.  I don’t grow them so I don’t have any first hand knowledge.  I found the following information from the Farmer’s Almanac.

Parsnips need a long growing season and are best harvested after a few fall frosts; if planted too late in the season, their roots will be small.
Water in summer if rainfall is less than 1 inch per week. Parsnips need a fair amount of moisture to form healthy roots.

As long as you started with good soil, fertilizing is likely not necessary. Excess nitrogen will encourage top growth instead of root growth.

Once roots start to form, hill soil around the plants’ base to prevent greening of the roots’ shoulders.

Poor Parsnip Plant Companions:  Carrots, Celery, Dill and Fennel.

For the rest of the summer I would be sure to give them plenty of water, especially since you compost probably drains really well and no fertilizer.

I hope this helps.


Deb Kroon Replied August 03, 2023, 11:00 AM EDT
Deb,

Thank you for your prompt response.  I did a soil test this morning with a Rapitest kit and all our levels appear to be adequate.  pH is fine.  The thing I don't like about this kit is that the test water color is never really comparable to the color charts.

Where could I get a lab soil test in MN?  I've looked at our Wabasha County website but didn't see any such service.

Attached is a pic of parsnips grown in these very same beds a few years ago.  Since then I have amended the beds as needed and have never over-applied any fertilizer component.

The sifted compost beds are certainly friable.  No question about that. They're a foot deep.   They do drain-off more quickly than just plain soil.  And last year, I added rock phosphate accurately at the end of the season.

So, no real clue why we're not getting root development on the parsnips.  My soil test did not indicate excess nitrogen.

Everything else is doing great.  No sign of leaf discolorations.

One interesting fact, tho.  We planted Brussels sprouts in both a bed and newly tilled soil with added compost.  The plants in the beds are smaller than the ones in the tilled soil.  


On Thursday, August 3, 2023, 10:00:09 AM CDT, Ask Extension <<personal data hidden>> wrote:


The Question Asker Replied August 04, 2023, 9:45 AM EDT

Some plants just need that real dirt!  Compost is great, but sometimes it is the nutrients in real dirt.  So maybe next year consider mixing in some black dirt with your compost.

If you go to Extension.umn.edu and search  soil testing, choose the article test your soil this spring and click on the red University of Mn soil testing lab it will give you where to send the sample and how to do it.

I still believe our hot dry summer has a lot to do with a lot of issues people are having this year.

Deb Kroon Replied August 04, 2023, 11:51 AM EDT

Loading ...