Thorny shrub identification - Ask Extension
Hello,
I came across this multi-trunked thorny shrub in a forest edge that I was clearing of honeysuckle. The apps suggest Clammy Locust, but there a...
Knowledgebase
Thorny shrub identification #820791
Asked February 21, 2023, 8:02 AM EST
Hello,
I came across this multi-trunked thorny shrub in a forest edge that I was clearing of honeysuckle. The apps suggest Clammy Locust, but there are currently no leaves or blooms to help with identification.
There are several of these growing together, all multi-trunked, and about 10 feet tall. Both honeylocust and black locust are in the vicinity.
Is there anyway to tell from these photos exactly what this might be?
Many thanks for your help!
Howard County Maryland
Expert Response
We agree the Robinia species in our region can be difficult to tell apart at this point (being both young and dormant) and we don't have a good resource that points-out the nuanced differences between the two species. Given how abundant Black Locust is in Maryland, it's likely to be that species, since Clammy Locust is quite rare (at least, few observations have been documented so far). We're pretty confident this is not a Honeylocust, though. If you decide to keep the plant for now, it might be easier to concretely identify once in bloom or producing seeds, though even one of our reference books states that Robinia species are sometimes very hard to distinguish from one another.
Miri
Miri
Thank you so much for your quick response! I didn’t realize clammy locust was quite so rare. I will keep an eye out on it as it blooms this summer, with great interest.
Thank you again.
You're welcome!