Knowledgebase

Oak tree bark peeling/breaking off #778141

Asked November 20, 2021, 9:36 AM EST

Hi, I have a cluster of four oak trees in my backyard. A few years an arborist told me that they looked healthy, and then this past year I noticed that on the west side of one tree, the bark is separating from the tree and breaking off. This is only happening on one of the three trees. Do you know what this indicates? Thank you for your time. Regards, Eleni

Montgomery County Maryland

Expert Response

We cannot say what caused the bark to separate and break off. There may be several reasons such as physical damage, root issues, poor drainage, etc. You did not mention what the canopy looks like and how you care for the tree. 

We recommend that you consult with a certified arborist for an onsite visit regarding the health of the tree. An arborist can assess the situation and recommend practices to support the tree's health if needed. 

Many mature oak trees are in decline in various locations in Maryland. Some contributing factors are described in the following articles:

https://extension.umd.edu/resource/why-oak-trees-are-declining-or-dying

https://extension.umd.edu/resource/browning-and-defoliation-white-oaks

You can find an arborist using this directory: https://www.treesaregood.org/findanarborist/arboristsearch.

Marian

Hi Marian,
Thanks for your note.   I will find another arborist to come out and check out the four oaks again.  Just wondering, would it be better to wait until spring?

The canopy seems fine.  Because of overhanging branches near my home, I did have a tree company trim branches last year.   I have not noticed any leaf damage except for the ends of the branches post-cicaidas.  The four oak trees, which are on a little hill, were well established when I moved into my home some 33 years ago.   When I cut the lawn, the grass stays and I mow/mulch the leaves in the fall.  If I should have been doing something special to care for them, I don't know what that would have been.

Again, thanks for your time.
Eleni Martin

On Tuesday, November 23, 2021, 11:26:03 AM EST, Ask Extension <<personal data hidden>> wrote:


The Question Asker Replied November 23, 2021, 12:06 PM EST

This is hard to say. It is probably fine but hazards can be hard to identify without seeing the situation on site. An ice or snow load might be risky. Legal implications of liability become fuzzy when a tree falls on a neighboring yard. It looks like many tree roots are outside your yard and is hard to know what stresses they experienced even if your tree care was fine. The bark is separating low on the trunk and the tree top is heavy looking.  You may not want to delay having the tree assessed.

Marian

Good points. Thank you. 


Sent from Yahoo Mail for iPhone

On Tuesday, November 23, 2021, 1:27 PM, Ask Extension <<personal data hidden>> wrote:

The Question Asker Replied November 23, 2021, 2:42 PM EST
Hi Marian,
I had an arborist come out today to look at my oak tree.   I wanted to close the loop and let you know that he said it was fine/nothing to worry about.  However, he did recommend using a ArborKelp Treatment + Mycorrhizae treatment.  The estimate provided said, " This unique biostimulant consists of sea kelp and other biologically active components that is highly recommended for stressed trees which are weakened as a result of construction, insect damage or transplant shock. Mycorrihizae has been added to recolonize the soil with these beneficial fungi."

Thank you again for your guidance.
Eleni

On Tuesday, November 23, 2021, 02:50:20 PM EST, Ask Extension <<personal data hidden>> wrote:


The Question Asker Replied November 29, 2021, 10:26 AM EST

Thank you for the update Eleni. When arborists recommend treatments for ailing trees (which can be costly in some cases), it's prudent to seek a second opinion. Similarly, make sure the assessments are made by certified arborists rather than just any tree-care professional; arborists have more thorough training and keep track of current science regarding tree care. For instance, scientific evidence has not concretely supported the use of mycorrhizae (as an additive) due to lack of any measured benefits for plants. (Healthy soils have plenty of mycorrhizae already present, and adding more doesn't necessarily benefit the plants, nor do we always know what species of microbes are needed; plus, if the soil isn't healthy enough to support naturally-occurring mycorrhizae, it probably won't support added mycorrhizae either.)

The kelp might be providing a few plant growth-stimulating hormones as well as a mild dose of fertilizer, but this would only temporarily boost a tree's appearance or growth if the core cause of its demise is tissue damage to the trunk or roots or chronic environmental stress. Therefore, we are skeptical this treatment would provide any substantial results. Usually, detaching bark is not a good sign and suggests damage to vital tissues in the trunk, though we are of course only going by photographs and the arborist should be able to do a thorough assessment in person.

If you are instead comfortable and satisfied with their assessment and treatment proposal, just keep an eye on the tree's canopy for signs of decline going forward. Bear in mind that decline in the canopy might manifest years after conditions initially caused damage or stress to other parts of the tree, so the lag time can make diagnosis challenging. Changes occurring gradually can be difficult for us to notice, especially on a tree this size, so one suggestion is to take pictures of the tree during early or midsummer (when the canopy is fully leafed-out) around the same time each year so you can compare how dense and full the canopy is; it will be easier this way to see areas thinning-out or a pattern of branch loss, should it occur in the future. If you notice decline in this way, then you can consult an arborist again to see if a condition that may not have been serious or urgent now has progressed into a hazard.

Miri

Whoa—you are amazing and such a wealth of information!!!    I hadn’t thought about investigating treatments.  

He was an arborist but I was thinking of getting another estimate too.   he suggested cutting off some deadwood on other trees, which makes sense and I asked for a quote on mostly taking down one leaning tree.  Cost of about $5000 which is A little Steep for me.  Sometimes I’ve had contractor offer me the “bethesda” price vs “silver spring” price.  I guess some folks assume we are all rolling in $$$$.  He didn’t do that, but I always wonder.  


Sent from Yahoo Mail for iPhone

On Monday, November 29, 2021, 2:39 PM, Ask Extension <<personal data hidden>> wrote:

The Question Asker Replied November 29, 2021, 3:10 PM EST

Loading ...