Knowledgebase

Deer-Resistant Holly #761805

Asked July 14, 2021, 5:45 PM EDT

My local nursery has been recommending a type of shrub that looks like the attached. It's some form of argentea, which I understood to be a type of holly. The thing is, in my area of eastern Long Island the deer are ravenous for holly. I have a deer fence (like this one in the article), but it gets jumped sometimes and I'm concerned about investing a lot in shrubbery and then getting it all eaten in the fall. 

So, is there a type of argentea you'd recommend?

The one they recommended is in the picture, but I can't recall the full name. Can you help ID it?


Thank you!

Suffolk County New York

Expert Response

It is difficult to ID plant from an image.  Sometimes it helps to see reproductive structures, it it produces them.  It is even more difficult to ID a hybrid or a plant that was selected as a new variety since many will have similar outward appearances.  You either need to rely on an expert who works with a particular plant or the place you purchase.  Some have experienced plant people who know their plants.  Others just want to sell their merchandise and do little else to obtain knowledge of the plants they sell.

Unless the variety you have has been selected to be distasteful to deer,   you probably should not buy the plant.  If you can get the name of the variety, you can sometimes find alternate sources of information that will help you care for the plant and give some idea of its resistance to wildlife.  I might be able to assist you further if you can get the  name of the variety of this plant and, if it is a hybrid, what the parent plants used to develop it.

Ed Replied July 15, 2021, 9:00 AM EDT

Hi Expert, it's osmanthus heterophyllus. Thoughts on deer resistance?

The Question Asker Replied July 15, 2021, 6:50 PM EDT

The spiny leaves tend to make the plant deer resistant. 

A cautionary story:

A few years ago, when we had a severe winter and the deer could not easily get to the grass under the snow, they started eating evergreens which they would not eat in the past.  Now, they have no issues with eating a variety of evergreens during the winter.

Lesson learned, deer will adapt so they may not like this particular holly now but they may decide to try it if they are desparate.  Be vigilant in the winter.

Ed Replied July 16, 2021, 9:59 AM EDT

Loading ...