Knowledgebase

Bronze birch borere #752770

Asked May 28, 2021, 5:33 PM EDT

I'm in Alsea, OR and planted 10 b. jacquemontii about 12 years ago. One died a couple of years ago and I just figured 'trees die'. But this year I noticed two others looking pretty distressed. In poking around, I learned about bronze birch borer, which apparently showed up in the valley about two years ago. I now understand it's been a serious problem in nearby Corvallis, OR . What a pest! So I have some questions. 1) how do I get rid of it; are the botanists nearby I can contact to see if they can inoculate/treat them? 2) Since they form a sort of allée, I'd like to replant and wonder if you varieties that are are borer-resistant, or have some resistance to them; and 3) where in Oregon can I get them? Thanks, I appreciate your help! Michael

Benton County Oregon

Expert Response

Hi Michael. Thank you for contacting ‘Ask Extension” with your questions about the Bronze Birch Borer Beetle. They have definitely become a problem in Oregon. The tell-tale sign of a dying birch tree due to borer is the wilting and dying of foliage starting from the top of the tree, along with D-shaped insect exit holes in the bark. The beetles attack a tree that is injured or has environmental stress.

Birch typically grow in shady, moist environments. When planted in hot, dry environments, the trees can become drought stressed and susceptible to beetle attack. Birch trees that are planted in full sun need more frequent irrigation. Borers are unable to survive in healthy trees. Keep trees vigorous with proper watering, fertilizing, and other cultural practices. Do not prune when adults emerge and seek oviposition sites (late April to mid-July) as the females are attracted to fresh cuts.

Unfortunately, The Whitebarked Himalayan birch (Betula jacquemontii) is listed as susceptible to the borer. Moderately susceptible birch includes gray birch (B. populifolia), whitespire birch (B. platyphylla japonica 'Whitespire'), yellow birch (B. alleghaniensis), sweet birch, black birch, cherry birch (B. lenta), paper birch, white birch and canoe birch (B. papyrifer). Those with low susceptibility (more resistant) include heritage birch, heritage river birch (B. nigra 'Heritage'), river birch and red birch (B. nigra). I can’t be much help in finding a source to purchase trees. We don’t endorse one nursery over another. I recommend you call your favorite nursery and see if they carry a cultivar you are interested in. They may be able to help you locate a source or special order for you. Dancing Oaks Nursery in Monmouth came up in a quick Google search as having several Birch varieties.

I’m including a link to an OSU publication titled: “Homeowner Guide to Managing Bronze Birch Borer in the Upper Klamath Basin” The information there is applicable to the entire state. Figure 7 in that document shows five stages of Birch Tree decline. A tree at level 1 -3 has a good chance of recovery while level 4 is less likely to survive and level 5 is basically dead. Removing trees that are unlikely to survive will disrupt the beetle’s life cycle and reduce the risk to the remaining trees. It’s recommended that you work with a licensed arborist to determine if treatment or tree removal is appropriate.

I hope this helps!

Deb K Replied May 29, 2021, 7:20 PM EDT

Hi Deb,

 

Thanks for the prompt and thoughtful response.

 

I did search the extension site and pulled off several docs including the one you link to. What a mess.

 

I searched a lot on Google, and am at the point of desperately searching for a licensed arborist/botanist to come and treat my nine surviving, beautiful b. jacquemontii. It seems there are only two such folk who spray/treat/inoculate birch in all of Benton County. One doesn’t come out to Alsea, and the second has yet to return my call.

 

I’m not sure where to turn next.

 

Mcihael

 

From: Ask Extension [mailto:<personal data hidden>]
Sent: Saturday, May 29, 2021 4:21 PM
To: mehill
Subject: Re: Bronze birch borere (#0022701)

 

The Question Asker Replied June 07, 2021, 12:50 PM EDT

Hi Michael, 

This is just a PS to Deb's message. We're sorry to hear you're still feeling stuck. 

Please know you're not alone in either challenges finding an arborist or difficulties with bronze birch borer. Lovely as birches are, in the climate of the Valley they are extra vulnerable to BBB, especially after last winter's storms took chunks out of many birches. It's one of those problems where there is really not a silver bullet, unfortunately, and other folks with birches have had similar experiences. 

There are relatively few arborists who treat for bronze birch borer in Benton County, and arborists are often overbooked, still catching up after last winter's storm damage. I recently waited 9 months+ to get an arborist to remove a sketchy tree, so I understand your frustration. 

One additional place to check for arborists, if you have not yet done so, is here: https://www.treesaregood.org/findanarborist

Here's wishing you and your birches good luck - and crossing my fingers that right arborist comes out of the woodwork and can make a difference for your trees. 

Kind regards - Elizabeth R., Program Staff

Hi Elizabeth,

 

What a kind and thoughtful response! Thank you very much!

 

Well, today, I called back the first arborist I spoke with who is licensed to spray and actually does that, and pleaded a desperate case and he agreed to come out!  Hurray! So I am MUCH relieved. He said he’ll be out later this month to see the situation (I have nine surviving trees). He does his spraying in the late winter, so won’t treat my trees until then. He’s the boss on this one.  And apparently there isn’t anything I can do until then, which is sad.

 

Weather conditions in Alsea are much wetter than Corvallis, and while of the original 10 I planted, one died two years ago, one doesn’t look like it will make until he comes next Jan; five look unscathed, and three have been attacked but are in stage one or two, so I am hopeful.

 

My next gambit was to call the City and the County and find out what they do and who does it.

 

Thank you very much for the arborist link.  I will keep it.

 

The b. nigra Heritage, which grows considerably taller than the b. jacquemontii I have, is a possibility for replacement; I look forward to talking with the sprayer guy about that.

 

I had zero idea about BBB, so just took the death of the first one as part of the course of M. Nature. Live and learn. I also have about 15 Japanese maples, and six clumps of tall quaking aspen, but so far I understand I don’t have to worry about them…more conversation with ‘the man’.

 

Again, thank you for your email. I really appreciated it.

 

Best and warmest cheers

Michael

 

From: Ask Extension [mailto:<personal data hidden>]
Sent: Tuesday, June 8, 2021 11:38 AM
To: mehill
Subject: Re: Bronze birch borere (#0022701)

 

The Question Asker Replied June 08, 2021, 4:31 PM EDT

Loading ...