Knowledgebase

Dying evergreen trees #748629

Asked May 07, 2021, 2:19 PM EDT

5-6 years ago I planted 3 trees that were 6’ tall. Last year one started loosing the Needles, thinking it was dying I remove the tree. Now the other two are really looking sick and dropping needles. Wondering if I have bad soil and/or if they can be saved??

Clackamas County Oregon

Expert Response

To lose such nice conifers is disappointing. I’m sorry.

Did you dig up the one you lost, to examine the roots? That could tell you a few things. Options include planting depth being too high or too deep. Root rots. Sometimes trees are planted with the twine, burlap, or metal root holders, and as the tree grows it is “strangled”. Circling roots can also girdle and kill a tree years after it was planted.

Describe how you planted the trees. How do you care for them. Irrigation? Fertilization? How do you care for your lawn? There are some lawn care products that can’t be used around conifers.

Do you see any signs of bark damage from insects or cankers?

And last but not least, what type of trees are these? We can determine if they naturally decline in our climate. (Yours looks a bit like one of the colored cedars, like White-tipped Deodar Cedar. The Oregon State Landscapes page shows other common cedar on the right of this page.)


I just happened to check my Spam folder and found your email response. Darn, I was disappointed I had not heard back.



Sent from myMail for iOS


Friday, May 7, 2021, 8:40 PM -0700 from <personal data hidden> <<personal data hidden>>:
The Question Asker Replied August 18, 2021, 5:43 PM EDT
Yes, I am sure the heat as made them worse. My neighbor is the Willard Dillard Nursery, also said that. I do see some fresh new growth. She suggested I take away the old needles under the tree, put a couple cups of Fertilizer and water, maybe they will come back?
In the passed I have used some Casoron Granules on my lawn boarders, can’t remember if I did any around the trees. On the lawn I use the Scott’s program.
Thanks so much for touching base with me. Now I’ll check Spam more often.  Cheers
Thanks   Len



Sent from myMail for iOS


Wednesday, August 18, 2021, 3:09 PM -0700 from Ask Extension <<personal data hidden>>:
The Question Asker Replied August 18, 2021, 6:35 PM EDT

The Extension Service advice is against fertilizer, as it can increase water requirements. This article, “Western Oregon conifers continue to show damage due to drought” gives that and other advice. Usually the needles naturally under the tree provide helpful mulch to hold soil moisture, but other organic mulch could be used.

The only tree I see that is going to live and look good in a landscape is the one in your middle photo. Watch them this winter, but I don’t expect the bare branches will get new needles.

When you remove a tree, check the roots to see if there were problems that led to the plant’s decline. Also, you’ll know what avoid when planting replacements. This publication from WSU shows some common problems and gives instructions for correct planting. “Planting Trees and Shrubs in the Landscape (Home Garden Series)”


Thank you for sharing the information, I’ll keep my fingers crossed.   Len

Forgot to hit send.. Cheers



Sent from myMail for iOS


Wednesday, August 18, 2021, 7:37 PM -0700 from <personal data hidden> <<personal data hidden>>:
The Question Asker Replied August 24, 2021, 11:32 AM EDT

Loading ...